Linux Advocate Dietrich Schmitz shows how the general public can take action to truly protect their privacy using GnuPG with Evolution email. Read the details.
Linux Advocate Dietrich Schmitz reminds CIOs that XP Desktops destined for MS end of life support can be reprovisioned with FOSS Linux to run like brand new. Read how.
Linux Advocate Dietrich Schmitz reminds readers of a long ago failed petition by Mathematician Prof. Donald Knuth for stopping issuance of Software Patents.
I am shaking my head and letting out a chuckle. Because today, I read how Ubuntu, or, Canonical Ltd., in their own infinite wisdom have decided to reinstate 'Menus' in select applications, including Nautilus. Good grief. So, throwing the baby out with the bath water wasn't a good idea after all? I should say not. I've been dead set against Unity from the beginning and have taken the position that it represents in its great desire to be 'different' a net software regression. Removing menus was a mistake and flies in the face of common sense and good sound design principles. That with a host of other changes which have essentially given Canonical Ltd firm control of their software development, including Mir, have placed them in total isolation from the community at large and distinguish Ubuntu as the only Distro that uses the novel Unity graphical user interface. Arguably, they have made some technology advancements, but to many, they have created a rift and wholesale development shift in avoidance of Unity and its attendant technical issues entirely. Wayland fortunately continues to progress and paves the way for Distros which plan to migrate away from the aged and complicated X.org Display driver semantics. This is a bridge that will be crossed soon and Mir will be the singular X.org replacement going forward for Ubuntu, unless they reverese their position and current thinking. It would really be in their best interests to support Wayland so as to be uniform with all upstream development but then Canonical Ltd., would yield control away from sole ownership of Mir and have to 'cow-tow' to the community or at least make an attempt to 'cooperate' and contribute to Wayland. But, that is the way it is. Live by the sword, die by the sword. Canonical Ltd. has made their own strategic business decisions and must live with them. It's not too late for them to come to their senses and drop Mir and support Wayland. It would be a good move. +Mark Shuttleworth you've done the right thing by standardizing on systemd. Don't be divisive. Adopt Wayland and dump the Mir project. Do the right thing. -- Dietrich
I've settled for largely avoiding Unity and Gnome3.x entirely. Most of you know that. No need to go over why.
But lately, I've been wondering why Fedora doesn't offer a Spin of OpenBox. So, my curiosity got the best of me and I installed it into Fedora 19 Xfce Spin.
The following files were installed:
openbox, obmenu, obconf, tint2, xfce4-mixer, xfce4-power-manager, clipit, and gmrun.
Then, create the following directory:
$mkdir ~/.config/openbox
and
$gedit ~/.config/openbox/autostart
and paste the following into it, save and close the file:
## Openbox autostart
## ====================
## Note*: some programs, such as 'nm-applet' are run via XDG auto-start.
## Run '/usr/lib/openbox/openbox-xdg-autostart --list' to list any
## XDG autostarted programs.
## GNOME PolicyKit and Keyring
#/usr/lib/polkit-1-gnome/polkit-gnome-authentication-agent-1 &
#eval $(gnome-keyring-daemon -s --components=pkcs11,secrets,ssh,gpg) &
#Starts Nitogen and restore wallpaper from previous session
#nitrogen --restore &
# start up the tint2 task bar
tint2 &
# Start up power management
xfce4-power-manager &
# Start the Clipboard manager after 3 seconds wait
(sleep 3s && clipit) &
# start volume manager after 3 seconds
#(sleep 3s && volti) &
The parts in autostart for policykit, nitrogen, and volti have been commented out as they don't currently work, or weren't found in the Fedora repo.
Logging out of Xfce, I selected the openbox window manager and logged back into Fedora 19.
Immediately, I was presented with a familiar (from my CrunchBang experiences) spartan grey screen and a panel on the bottom (tint2).
Utterly minimal, but exceedingly fast, OpenBox on Fedora 19
Autostart was able to load the power-manager, chrome and the clipboard. nm-applet loaded and connected to wireless automatically also without need for configuration.
Currently, there is no volume icon in the tray (not a crisis as I can launch pavucontrol or xfce4-mixer to adjust settings if need be).
Probably, I'll figure out what to do about volti and nitrogen tomorrow and add maybe a few other tweeks like conky, but this is quite doable for now.
OpenBox is a stacking window manager. On a Netbook, you need to ring out all of the resources and mine has 2GB ram. Reaching the Desktop, opening a terminal and checking free returns about 140MB ram used. That really can't be beat, unless maybe you install Bodhi Linux or Puppy Linux or DSL. The speed improvement is quite marked.
I am sure there will be comments from those getting less ram usage. Still you get the point.
I'll use this for a while and see how it goes.
So Folks, when you want minimalism and speed, check out OpenBox. It never disappoints.
Opinions are like colons; everybody has one. And so do I. Daily, I see changes on Distrowatch.com and ask myself: "What does it mean for the future of Linux?". (Image credit: netanimations.net)
I wonder where it will be in five years. Given the rapid pace of technology change, it's hard to fathom if things will even resemble what they are today.
In my private LA community, we 'chew the fat' and often one person or another expresses their favor for one particular Distro over another. That is to be expected.
But I've reached the point where I don't want to keep switching Distros. The younger Folk love to tinker and try various flavors and that's fine. It's a great learning experience for anyone who has the penchant to do so. Linux affords limitless opportunity to learn--a great thing.
No, I've decided to stay put with my favorite Distro. It makes most sense to me. I've given up on Canonical and see their business plans as being confused and misdirected. My endorsement for Ubuntu is gone now because their preoccupation with Unity is totally lost on me--it departs from common sense GUI principles. Combined with the fact that they have had little mass-market penetration in the U.S. and you see a floundering commercial Distribution.
No, Canonical is moving sideways as sugardaddy Elitist Mark Shuttleworth pours more IOUs into the balance sheet of a company in the red.
Say what you will, but he has taken the company down the primrose path. Even now, with Ubuntu's Unity, they have spun off Ubuntu Touch in the furtherance of their Mobile Smartphone project. Exactly how Canonical will differentiate themselves in the face of overwhelming competition coming from the likes of a multiplicity of Android OEMs, Apple's iPhone, Mozilla's Firefox phone remains in doubt. That they face strong headwinds on that front is an understatement.
Quite clearly, the Linux landscape will radically change and there will be only a few Distros left standing five years from now. Which ones? It seems likely only the ones with the largest organizational infrastructure and the ability to innovate will remain. All of the smaller Distro Teams? Well, they are merely drafting behind the big Distros and playing a game of cookie cutter 'me too'. When you look at the situation as I have, there are only a handful of Distros which have something in the way of good technology to set them apart. All the rest are merely copy cats.
That's right copy cats. They aren't doing anything illegal mind you. That's the GPLv2 at work. But where will your Distro be in five years? Mine will still be around, I am quite confident of that. The rest are inconsequential 'side effects' of a licensing scheme which promotes experimentation.
And Canonical, moving sideways, will be gone in five years.
I've been a regular reader of Dedoimedo and have to say, to the best of my recollection, my colleague's review of Ubuntu 13.04 Raring Ringtail is the most candid one he has ever written.
There have been times in the past when I disagreed with him in his assessment of various Distros, but this time, I have to take sides with him. I mean, please, don't hold back on the reader's account. LOL. And no, hold back Dedoimedo does not.
Oh, it gets quite colorful.
His diatribe begins with 'A New Definition of Pain: Ubuntu'. That should give the reader a clue what he has in store for them.
Let's sample some of his more colorful use of the English language shall we?:
On Nouveau
"Remember my praise for improvements in the open-source driver? Well, not anymore, not with the Unity based flavor of Ubuntu, that is. In Ringtail, the performance of this driver was appalling. The system was virtually unusable. Moreover, to make things worse, Canonical has gracefully taken away Unity 2D, taken away a fallback session that uses a basic VESA driver, because that is not chic. And this means you have to eat some brown cakes made from human leftovers, and by leftovers, I mean crap."
On System Core Utilization and Network Speed
"Compiz was taking easily between 120-180% CPU alone. Exacerbating the problem was the network speed, which we will discuss shortly, forcing me to wait many long minutes until the driver was downloaded from the local repo, at approx. 1/50 the expected rate.
And so I waited, like the little masochist that I am."
On Restarting
"Indeed, I foolishly thought restarting the network might solve the problems. Yes, open command line and run the init script with the restart argument. That's all. Right. You've all done it hundreds of times without any problems whatsoever.
What it did was kill the desktop. Ubuntu then threw an error how it encountered a serious problem and all that nonsense. Restart lightdm, no help. Reboot. Unbootable desktop. I am not joking. That's right, fellas. Restarting the network ruined the X configuration. At this point, I totally gave up."
On Taking Ownership of the Issues (by Canonical)
"For some reason, it's everyone's fault except the people making and packaging the software. They are pristine, innocent little angels, and they shed tears that cure cancer. Only it seems to me, the reality is somewhat different. Starting with Lucid onwards, which was absolutely rock solid, stable, fast, and everything worked just splendid, on this very same hardware, things are getting progressively worse. In the rush to complete with the already rabid market, QA is dumped down the drain as second best, when it should be the top priority."
On Quality Assurance
"Non-LTS releases should NOT be made available to general public. Not the way they are nowadays. They should be labeled strictly beta. The only thing they manage to achieve is cause harm, to users, to enthusiasts, to people who wish to promote Linux, and to the company itself. I dread to think what will happen once Wayland and Mir come along. This is going to be C.L.U.S.T.E.R. foobar of colossal magnitude. I seriously consider not testing the next release. Just skipping it."
On Unity: The 'Cherry de la Turd'
"Even more stupendously stupefying is that Kubuntu 13.04 and Xubuntu 13.04 Ringtails are probably among the best, most polished versions of said distros released, ever. Yup. I was almost tempted to grant a perfect score to each one of them. My simple conclusion would be that Unity adds its own layer of problems that is not present in the other two. And this make our problem a tad more problematic. Awesome."
Ubuntu's Overall Score
"Overall, the Unity-based flavor of Raring Ringtail, I repeat the Unity-based flavor, not Kubuntu or Xubuntu, which are quite alright really, deserves 0/10."
Seriously Folks, I left much out, but I think it becomes pretty clear after reading Dedoimedo's review in its entirety that Raring Ringtail suffers from multiple serious quality control issues. As a result, the reviewer gives this product a FAIL, having a score total of 0/10. Wow.
So, consider yourself warned: avoid Ubuntu 13.04 like the proverbial plague.
I am beginning to see a pattern in how Canonical operates. Not to single them out, but I think that to succeed in any business endeavor, a business plan must set objectives with a timeline to their completion.
It seems that Canonical are setting their own priorities. First came Unity. Then they targeted X.org a standard for Display management by supporting Wayland. As Wayland reached its first production release, version 1.0, Canonical immediately took the code and forked it to their own project specification called Mir. (Image credit: inhabit.com)
This is looking less like an open community than any other time I can remember. Canonical are carefully taking control their code base and removing community involvement.
Then, Canonical developed a new fork called Ubuntu Touch for their planned smartphone division.
Now, they've announced a plan to develop their own package management software, with the 'intention' (cough wink) of using it for their smartphone technology.
This has garnered much attention and the noise level continues to amplify.
What if the plans for this new package manager were more ambitious than Canonical are telling us? Suppose that package management system would take away the Debian apt/dkpg control?
That would not bode well for Debian, me thinks. And I've advocated for a unified package manager. One because it would dramatically ease the burden of programming and two it would reduce costs and allow software written to be packaged and run on allLinux Distros.
That isn't my idea. Actually, it's been around for years in fact and is part of the Linux Foundation's Linux Standard Base (LSB). In fact, rpm is the standard which is a 'mandatory' specification to obtain LSB certification.
Debian have resisted support for rpm and LSB which may work ultimately to their disadvantage if they continue to ignore the standard.
Debian is not a commercial Linux Distribution. So, they can afford to play foot-loose and fancy free by ignoring standards in favor of their own 'de facto' standard.
But how long will that last? They took two years to roll out Debian 7 Wheezy which still runs on sysvinit, not systemd, although they've made systemd an installable option. Two years is slow people. Debian is looking old, stodgy, and resistant to change. And, as we all know, technology is changing at the speed of light.
So, is Canonical running their own railroad? Necessarily, to run a business, yes. They and Red Hat can't afford to play around like Debian and Canonical just might switch away from deb package management entirely to again gain control of another big piece of the Linux Distro puzzle. Let's hope that Canonical recognize the importance of LSB and support rpm. -- Dietrich
With all of the insane decision making that has taken place at Canonical with Unity and The Gnome Project with Gnome 3.8 just out, it can make a grown Man cry in despair.
But fear not. Hope is on the horizon. You do fortunately have Desktop alternatives to avoid the madness and chaos that looms.
I'll cover a few of them here so at least you are apprised of your options.
Xfce
I currently enjoy the serenity of this nimble Desktop. It's truly a great option for those suffering refugees coming away from a bad experience with the terror of Unity and Gnome 3.x. The beauty of Xfce is that it uses GTk2 libaries and will take you back to a Gnome 2.x experience albeit with a slice of Xf playing into the mix. It really does the job of giving you what you want and a large degree of flexibility in configuration options. Best of all, its memory footprint is meager and you'll discover that it breathes life back into your rig as screens snap up crisply with no delay. Add a few nice themes and fonts and enable the built-in compositor and, presto change-o, you have the essential ingredients for a truly efficient but pleasant Desktop Environment. Having dependencies on GTk2 means that there is no reliance upon Gnome whatsoever, which should be in your best interests and incorporated into your strategy for avoiding pain.
LXDE
Even leaner than Xfce, LXDE brings a somewhat spartan GUI experience but really gets the job done. It isn't sexy by any means but for the minimalists, having the DE sip ram reigns supreme. LXDE does that exceedingly well.
MATE
It was over a year ago that Clem Lefevre of Linux Mint fame chose to fork Gnome 2.3x to MATE. During that same period, he also chose to fork Gnome 3.x to Cinnamon. It was truly ambitious for an outfit with limited resources such as Mint to have undertaken at the time, but Clem prevailed and succeeded in doing so. The key issue to be mindful of with MATE and Cinnamon is that both suffer from falling behind on code maintenance, especially MATE. Still, if you long for the good old days and miss Gnome 2.3x, then, by all means, jump on MATE and feel immediate relief as the nostalgia sets in. [Edit: MATE released version 1.6 on 4/3/2013, so that's a plus; also I have been advised that Clem forked Cinnamon, not MATE see the comments directly below from +Maik Adamietz who clarified the issue on my private LA G+ community site. ]
+Dietrich Schmitz i just noticed something in the MATE part. It wasn't Clement Lefebvre (Clem) at all who chose to fork Gnome 2.3x to MATE. Clem just jumped in on the MATE project as project management, he manages the releases, does the communication and provides the hosting.
Perberos (a guy from Arch) was the one who decided to fork Gnome 2.3X into MATE. He's the one that is the projects founder, developer and packaging MATE for Arch Linux:
What can I say about KDE? +Aaron Seigo, I take my hat off to you and the KDE Team. This is the true benchmark for all other Linux Desktop Environments to be measured by. I won't equivocate and will simply say that if your PC has 4GB ram, go straight to KDE and enjoy the luxury and prestige of running a DE replete with eye candy and an unparalleled feature set. KDE truly is the champion Desktop Environment, bar none.
KLyDE
Well, +Aaron Seigo and Team are at it again. They've got a new lightweight KDE desktop in the works. It's not soup yet, but it will be only a matter of time before we can sink our teeth into this DE. I for one am looking forward to giving it a spin. Aaron give me a heads up when you have something, yes?
Razor-Qt
Well, this is ambitious and quite clever and I am happy to see that it was done by someone. Razor-Qt gives the immediate feeling of KDE yet gets you all of the basics with no fanfare. Of course, it uses the Qt framework which gives it that tell tale look of quality and style that I enjoy and you will too. The memory footprint is lean and this will be an obvious choice for those with older PCs configured with less ram as well as Netbook users like myself.
[Edit: 4/28/2013 19:33 GMT-5 Someone gave me a heads up in the comments section, I forgot Enlightenment E17. Eeeek. Major blunder and effusive apologies.]
Other Desktop Window Managers (WMs)
I would be remiss and catch major flack from the readers if I failed to mention a few of the Window Managers that have gained popularity among the technophiles. WMs tend to be exceedingly lightweight in memory consumption and awesomely fast, yet, they might also be less user-friendly. They do in truth have a performance edge, no question, but reaching proficiency and configuration can both be a challenge.
I'll just give a mention on each because, really, I am an ignoramous extraordinaire when it comes to WMs, I readily admit. A few of my friends' DEs look like they work for the NASA Space Center and it scares me. ;)
Tiling Window Managers
Awesome
i3
dwm
Matchbox
Tritium
wmii
xmonad
Stacking Window Managers
Awesome
FluxBox
OpenBox
IceWM
Sawfish
Window Maker
I see it coming--I've left someone's favorite WM out of the list. Hanging my head in shame--I am not worthy. ;) Seriously, there are so many and I can only say go and look on Wikipedia and sample from their lists and decide if WMs are for you.
Well, as you can plainly see, you are not a caged animal and do have a recourse. There are so many good GUI options from which to choose that one can be quite happy and maintain one's sanity in the presence of such disasters the likes of Unity and Gnome 3.8.
Get out there and give them a try. There is hope and You have options.
The premise has always been that open source development should thrive and be guided by consensus and openness.
Consensus in the sense that a community who share in the development of a given application or Linux Distro energizes participation and guides teamwork when all recognize they have a role in moving toward a desired group goal in a cooperative effort.
The idea that computer software source code can be shared and reused and improved, provided that such changes to code are given back is central to the open source Gnu Public License v2.
No effort to move forward under the GPLv2 License is more symbolic than the collective work embodied by the Linux Kernel.
Many projects have been produced using the GPL as the basis for development for various 'moving parts' of the Linux Distribution (Distro), including system middle-ware components, utilities, and graphical Desktop Environments all working together in concert, meshing seamlessly to render the Distro experience.
To a large extent each software project has its own community with various responsibilities that combine to achieve the project's goals. Communities around a project vary in size and as the organization dictates the size will grow according to the demands and initiatives undertaken by its members.
When consensus is taken and the feedback results in new design decisions and new feature enhancements, new branches of code are created to facilitate new major software revisions. Committers who officially contribute code to a project typically store their changes in a central repository using Internet software revision control systems such as Git, or Subversion. Revision control software will carefully track 'deliverables' and maintain versioning of a project through its software life cycle.
But when consensus is made but not incorporated into a decision making process, there is no longer a continuity between goals and objectives that everyone can accept.
The decisions made by a few people in power and only those people is being referred to here in this context as Elitism.
Risks of Operating in an Elitist Environment
By default, Elitism is exclusionary and ignores shared responsibility in the decision making process for a given project or organization. Elitism promotes social stratification and division and gives those few decision makers a sense of privileged special status.
The risks inherent in working for an organization or for a project which is controlled by Elitism is that morale will suffer as team members discover their input on decisions doesn't matter.
Often Defeatist Elitism takes control of an otherwise open decision making process where the individual charged with making the final choice will with impunity put down or discourage collaboration and either verbally or in writing show dissatisfaction toward individuals bringing their own ideas to a group discussion.
In addition to harming morale, members in a group effort will be less inclined to take initiative and do independent learning, and many will become exasperated at seeing their work or ideas not being given credit and simply resign from active participation.
This can hurt the reputation of the organization or project and result in a loss of competing market share. The level of risk for having made a bad strategic decision and continuing to support its advancement increases in likelihood, despite however bad the choice was or the probability of failure is, under an elitist's tight control.
Signs of Elitism
Watching the progress of Canonical, it is becoming increasingly evident that the culture of Ubuntu software development is severely hampered by the elitist behavior of Mark Shuttleworth:
Making a choice to move to Unity and choke off support for rearward compatibility with Gnome 2.3x feature sets is magnified by the proliferation of third-party utilities to tweak the GUI and fill major feature regressions.
Radical changes to remove a traditional, intuitive Menu Structure (Gnome 2.3x Applications Places System Menu) in favor of 'searching' for an application is a strong warning sign that common sense traditional methods have taken a back seat to whimsical ideas and a 'we know best' what users need on their Desktop.
Devoting major development efforts in Unity to allow searches of Amazon from the Desktop (vs. a browser) is another warning sign that in the shadow of one Man's elitist control, the direction and reputation of Ubuntu have taken a U-turn away from acceptable use in violation of users' privacy rights. In spite of cries discouraging its implementation, the Amazon Lens went into Ubuntu 12.10 but has since included a system toggle to disable it by default.
Despite being an up-hill battle with little chance of gaining significant market share, Canonical now has plans to build a smartphone running Ubuntu with Unity, only called Ubuntu Touch.
Conclusion
So, the danger of an open source project's goals being precluded and derailed by Elitism are a big concern. One might say even, the risk that Ubuntu is leaning towards becoming proprietary is not out of the realm of possibility.
Ubuntu Linux--It's one big flashing road side billboard Folks--Elitism at work.